Tuesday, August 31, 2004

Oh...the military delegates at the GOP Convention are reservists....

According to Eric Alterman, it seems that the "active" military personnel who are delegates at the Republican National Convention are reservists, so they are okay to be delegates:

"Update on my Possible Actual News Alert: According to our man Bateman, whom we should have contacted in the first place, the Republican Party is not in violation of the U.S. military’s rules on the participation in party politics by active duty military, owing to the reserve status of the delegates."

We have to ask, though, if the reserves are being sent into active duty, why is there a distinction for political activity and not being sent to Iraq?

Monday, August 30, 2004

Active servicemen serving as delegates?

The following appears today in Eric Alterman's column online on msnbc.com. (For the entire column: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/3449870/) Props to Michael Galletly for his vigilance! We at The Thinking Woman hesitate to call this a conspiracy (although the word has been muttered) but it certainly seems to be something the Republican Party itself would be anxious to clear up. The last thing they want is an appearance of inpropriety as they are the party of the sitting president:

Possible Actual News Alert: Is the Republican Party in violation of the US military’s rules on the participation in party politics by active duty military?

It sure looks that way. The RNC convention week is boasting that it has 144 active duty military delegates at the convention or three percent of the total. That information can be found here.

Meanwhile, according to DOD Directive 1344.10, which can be found here this is a violation of the code of military conduct.

It explicitly says:

"A member on active duty shall not ... Participate in partisan political management, campaigns, or conventions (unless attending a convention as a spectator when not in uniform)."

But the Republican Party itself is claiming that the active duty personnel are not spectators but delegates. What’s going on here? Why are the Republicans encouraging our soldiers to violate the Uniform Code of Military Justice and its stated rules of political engagement? And why for goodness sakes, aren’t these rules being enforced?

Hey MSNBC.com, can we put a reporter or two on this story please?

(Thanks to Altercation reader Michael Galletly of Norman, OK.)

Wednesday, August 25, 2004

Cheney Earns our Admiration

The thinking women behind The Thinkingwoman are not given to praising Republicans too often, so imagine our surprise when we have good things to say about two of them in a given week. However, in a New York Times article by Robin Toner this morning (Aug. 25) Cheney was quoted about his opinion on gay marriage.

--- In a political season marked by Republican efforts to outlaw gay marriage, Vice President Dick Cheney on Tuesday offered a defense of the rights of gay Americans, declaring that "freedom means freedom for everyone" to enter "into any kind of relationship they want to."

--- Mr. Cheney said the issue was what kind of government recognition to give those relationships, and indicated that he preferred to let the states define what constitutes a marriage.

The critics immediately started sniping that Cheney was only trying to soften the harsh tone of the Bush administration calling for a constitutional amendment to prevent gay marriage. We believe otherwise. Back in 2000 we were struck by the civil and intelligent content of Cheney’s debate with then vice presidential nominee Joe Lieberman. During their discussion the issue of the place of homosexuals in our society came up and both men agreed that they needed to learn more and remain open-minded about the topic. Since that time, Cheney has admitted that one of his two daughters is gay and has stated that he is as proud of her as her sister.

This doesn’t sound like a man who is playing a game for his administration. This strikes us as a good father who is standing by what he believes in spite of his party’s platform. We’d like to offer our praise and encouragement for this principled stance. We only wish we saw more of this in politics.

Tuesday, August 24, 2004

John McCain and the 2004 presidential election

We at The Thinking Women are fans of John McCain, the moderate Republican senator from Arizona. We have found ourselves frequently discussing him lately. We liked him as a running mate for John Kerry, and, for that matter, we liked him as the Republican presidential candidate in 2000. (And, for that matter, he'd make a great running mate for George W. Bush!)

Which brings up why he is being discussed by us so much now. It turns out that the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth are essentially the same group of people who ran a successful negative ad campaign against John McCain in 2000, enabling George W. Bush to gain the Republican nomination. And so, instead of running for re-election as president, Sen. McCain is running for re-election as senator in Arizona. (If being a war veteran were the main criteria for being president, there's no question his experiences and heroism far outstrips anyone else who has run for the office of president in the last twenty years. )

One of us was led to comment today that if John McCain were president, America wouldn't be in the mess we are today. And we asked (as we seem to do almost weekly), how could the GOP nominate George W. Bush over John McCain?

Which brings us back to the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth. The conservative right appears to, right now, have the power (especially the money) in the Republican Party and they, by hook or crook (heh heh) got their candidate into office. John McCain is too moderate for the Republicans right now. Which is sad, because the country is being denied the Republican who has the true potential to unite a polarized nation.

The Swift Boat "controversy" -- enough already!

This thoughtful commentary on the "Swift Boat controversy was printed today in the New York Times. Following the commentary is my letter I wrote to the editor of the Times, after reading it:

On Cable, a Fog of Words About Kerry's War Record
August 24, 2004
By ALESSANDRA STANLEY

There is the fog of war and then there is the fog of cable.

Over the last few weeks, 24-hour news networks have done little to find out what John Kerry did in Vietnam, but theyhave provided a different kind of public service: their examination of his war record in Vietnam illustrates once again just how perfunctory and confusing cable news coverage can be. Facts, half-truths and passionately tendentious opinions get tumbled together on screen like laundry in an industrial dryer - without the softeners of fact-checking or reflection.

Somehow, on all-cable news stations - CNN as well as Fox News - a story that rises or falls on basic and mostly verifiable facts blurs into just another developing news sensation alongside the latest Utah kidnapping or the Scott Peterson murder trial. (It is particularly confusing on FoxNews, where so many of its blond female anchors look like Amber Frey.)

Fox News, which delivers its news with "Fight Club"ferocity, has relished the controversy the most, seizing hungrily on charges that Mr. Kerry lied to gain his medals. Those accusations, which have not been substantiated, were made in the book "Unfit for Command," co-written by a former Swift boat commander and longtime Kerry critic, John O'Neill. Fox News has pushed the story early, often, and sometimes even late.

Yesterday, President Bush denounced all third-party campaign ads, including the ads by a group called Swift Boat Veterans for Truth, and called his opponent's war record admirable. Fox anchors made note of that development, then raced back to the disparaging remarks former Senator Bob Dole made to CNN on Sunday about Mr. Kerry's Purple Heart medals. ("Never bled that I know of,"said Mr. Dole, who was badly wounded in World War II.)

Fox News showed, again, a clip of Mr. Dole complaining that it was hypocritical of Kerry, a former opponent of the war, to run now as a proud Vietnam veteran. The Fox anchor Laurie Dhue then turned to her liberal guest, Elaine Kamarck, a former Gore campaign adviser.

"I mean, this does make it sound like he speaks from both sides of his mouth on this," Ms. Dhue said. "Could this hurt the Kerry campaign?"

Ms. Kamarck disagreed.

Fred Barnes, the executive editor of The Weekly Standard and a regular Fox commentator, ardently defended the Swiftboat critics of Mr. Kerry, saying on Fox that a majority of the senator's Vietnam brethren believed that Mr. Kerry"fabricated or exaggerated his record." Mr. Barnes added that "the entire chain of command above Kerry have said the same thing." He did not mention any notable exceptions in that chain of command, including Senator John W. Warner, Republican of Virginia, a former secretary of the Navy who said Mr. Kerry fully merited the Silver Star. Mr. Barnes's hyperbole went unchecked.

CNN showed less relish over the Swift boat clash, but it was not much more helpful in separating fact from friction. Wolf Blitzer's interview with the tart-tongued Mr. Dole made a lot of news on Sunday, but CNN allowed him to make misleading assertions without pointing out where he was in error. Mr. Dole suggested that Mr. Kerry was in a rush to obtain his Purple Hearts to meet a regulation that allowed soldiers to leave the war zone after winning three. "Imean, the first one, whether he ought to have a Purple Heart - he got two in one day, I think. And he was out of there in less than four months, because three Purple Hearts and you're out." ( Mr. Kerry did not receive two Purple Hearts for events of the same day. He received them for the events of Dec. 2, 1968; Feb. 20, 1969; and March 13, 1969.)

Finally, yesterday afternoon, Mr. Blitzer spoke to Mr. Dole by telephone and asked him if he regretted any of his statements. Mr. Dole said he did not.

"I wasn't trying to be mean-spirited," Mr. Dole said. "Iwas just trying to say all these guys on the other side just can't be Republican liars."

That kind of air-kiss coverage is typical of cable news, where the premium is on speed and spirited banter rather than painstaking accuracy. But it has grown into a lazy habit: anchors do not referee - they act as if their reportage is fair and accurate as long as they have two opposing spokesmen on any issue.

Fox commentators like Bill O'Reilly and Sean Hannity are famous for their informal, intemperate manner of speech. But the debate on programs like "Crossfire," on CNN, is often as heated - and as full of hot air. On an Aug. 12 edition about the Swift boat debate, a program regular, Robert Novak, the conservative columnist, called Mr. O'Neill and his fellow anti-Kerry veterans "the real patriots to rise to the surface this election year."

James Carville, Mr. Novak's liberal counterpart, challenged Mr. O'Neill's co-author, Jerome Corsi, charging that Mr.Corsi's blog is "scabrous." When Mr. O'Neill tried to change the subject, Mr. Carville shrieked at him.

At best, cable news programs swing into action when a crisis or major news development occurs, marshaling their resources to give viewers instant, live access. At their worst, they amplify the loudest voices and blur complexities. People can blame the confusion of combat for some of the discrepancies over Mr. Kerry's war record, but cable has done little to clear the air.

http://www.nytimes.com/2004/08/24/politics/campaign/24watch.html?ex=1094371553&ei=1&en=4697a6873ed58ccf

Copyright 2004 The New York Times Company

Here is my letter:

I have just finished reading Alessandra Stanley's excellent piece on the media's coverage of the "Swift boat controversy."

I, for one, am sick of the whole thing. John Kerry is not the only person to serve in Vietnam, then come back and protest the war. George W. Bush isn't the only rich kid to avoid active service.

It's as if everything else both men have done in their lives is pointless next to decisions they made when they were kids in their 20s. There is a reason the writers of the Constitution assigned a minimum age of 32 for the person to hold the office of president. We make different decisions at each point in our life.

I am much more interested in what's happening now. Bush's policies have alienated the United States from the rest of the world. There is a huge deficit because of a tax cut that benefits only the top one percent of income earners. Health care is in a state of crisis. The country is even more polarized than it was when Bush went into office. War veterans have the worst support from the government they've had, ever. The current administration policies are decemating the environment, and we're in the middle of a war that is beginning to resemble Vietnam: A war Kerry was lucky enough to escape intact from, as were the majority of his critics, and Bush was lucky enough to avoid fighting in.

Instead of hearing about both candidates' pasts, I want to hear from George W. Bush how our country is better off than it was when he took office. And I want both candidates to give me detailed agendas for their administrations. I, for one, want to select a candidate based on a concrete plan for America, not on emotion and accusations.


Wednesday, July 14, 2004

Senate blocks amendment against gay marriage

Whether you hold fast to traditional beliefs that heaven ordained that marriage is between a man and a woman, or feel that love cannot be contained by the values of the past, the push for a constitutional amendment to define marriage is of critical importance to all Americans. The American Consititution was not meant for abolishing the rights of Americans. Changing the constitution sets a dangerous precedent.

In addition, the amendment proposal distracts the public from the important issues of our day -- terrorism, war, health care, social security, the environment, education and unemployment. It has become a re-election hatchet wielded by viscious hands. Fortunately, the Senate has seen this and will not be forced into a vote. To find out why, read below.

> Senate Vote Blocks Effort to Ban Gay-Marriage in Constitution
> July 14, 2004
> By CARL HULSE
> New York Times
>>
> WASHINGTON, July 14 - Backers of a constitutional amendment
> to prohibit same-sex marriages suffered a stinging defeat
> in the Senate today as opponents easily killed the
> initiative for the year in a procedural showdown.
>
> Senators voted 50 to 48 against a call to cut off debate,
> 12 votes short of the 60 required and even below a simple
> majority of 51. It would have taken 67 votes to approve the
> amendment itself. The loss effectively ended a drive to
> move the proposal through the Senate before the November
> elections. Six Republicans helped block the amendment,
> illustrating the divisions in the party ranks over the idea
> of inscribing such a ban into the Constitution.
>
> "The constitutional amendment we are debating today strikes
> me as antithetical in every way to the core philosophy of
> Republicans," said Senator John McCain, Republican of
> Arizona. "It usurps from the states a fundamental authority
> they have always possessed, and imposes a federal remedy
> for a problem that most states do not believe confronts
> them."
>
> Three Democrats sided with Republicans in trying to move to
> a vote on the language of the amendment itself. Under
> constitutional rules crafted by the Founding Fathers to
> make it difficult to alter the document, a supermajority of
> 67 votes is necessary to start the ratification process by
> the states. Today's vote did not reflect the full level of
> opposition since some Senate Republicans who were opposed
> to the amendment sided with their leadership on the
> preliminary vote.
>
> "This is an unnecessary amendment that wrongly and
> certainly prematurely deprives states of their traditional
> ability to define marriage," said Senator Joseph Lieberman,
> Democrat of Connecticut, as he joined many of his
> colleagues in asserting that marriage is an issue of state
> domain.
>
> Democrats also accused the Senate Republican leadership of
> forcing the debate on an amendment they knew could not pass
> to create a wedge issue for the coming elections. President
> Bush is a strong supporter of the proposal and conservative
> activist groups had aggressively urged the Senate
> leadership to bring the matter to the floor.
>
> Backers of the amendment said they were only responding to
> court decisions they said were reshaping the traditional
> American view of marriage despite scant involvement on the
> part of the public.
>
> "Marriage does matter," said Senator Wayne Allard,
> Republican of Colorado and the author of the amendment. "It
> matters to our children, it matters in America. Marriage is
> the foundation of a free society and courts are redefining
> marriage."
>
> Though they lost the vote, the backers of the amendment did
> succeed in getting lawmakers on record on the issue and
> they said they expected it to reverberate throughout the
> campaign season. Senators John Kerry of Massachusetts and
> John Edwards of North Carolina, the two members of the
> Democratic presidential ticket, did not vote. They both
> oppose the amendment, however, saying that while they
> oppose same-sex marriage, the issue is a state concern.
>
> "The floor of the United States Senate should only be used
> for the common good, not issues designed to divide us for
> political purposes," Mr. Kerry said in a statement today.
> "Throughout history, amending our Constitution - the
> foundation of the nations values and ideals - has been
> serious business.
>
> "However, even Republicans concede that this amendment is
> being offered only for political gains. The unfortunate
> result is that the important work of the American people -
> funding our homeland security needs, creating new and
> better jobs, and raising the minimum wage - is not getting
> done.
>
> "Had this amendment reached a final vote, I would have
> voted against it, because I believe that the American
> people deserve better than this from their leaders. When I
> am president, I will work to bring the nation together and
> build a stronger America."
>
> The issue may still resurface in the House this year. A
> House panel was considering today a legislative proposal
> that its authors said could prevent federal judges from
> overturning the existing federal law defining marriage as
> being between a man and a woman, though critics said they
> doubted the new proposal could survive a court test.
>
> The House majority leader, Tom DeLay, has said he might
> schedule a House vote later this year on a constitutional
> amendment.
>
> The defeat in the Senate today came as no surprise. The
> Senate majority leader, Bill Frist, had already
> acknowledged that the amendment was unlikely to advance but
> said that the Senate action would be far from the last
> word.
>
> "This is the start," Dr. Frist said on Tuesday. "And it's
> not going to be over tomorrow. We'll be back in the
> future."


Wednesday, June 23, 2004

The Second Bill of Rights

The following is an article that appeared in the June 11, 2004 online issue of The Chronicle Review, a chronicle for higher education. This is a thoughtful analysis of what the rights of Americans can be -- beyond those listed in the Constitution:

We Need to Reclaim the Second Bill of Rights


By CASS R. SUNSTEIN

On January 11, 1944, the United States was involved in its longest conflict since the Civil War. The effort was going well. In a remarkably short period, the tide had turned sharply in favor of the Allies. Ultimate victory was no longer in serious doubt. The real question was the nature of the peace.

At noon, America's optimistic, aging, self-assured, wheelchair-bound president, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, delivered his State of the Union address to Congress. His speech wasn't elegant. It was messy, sprawling, unruly, a bit of a pastiche, and not at all literary. But because of what it said, this address, proposing a Second Bill of Rights, has a strong claim to being the greatest speech of the 20th century.

In the last few years, there has been a lot of discussion of World War II and the Greatest Generation. We've heard much about D-Day, foreign occupations, and presidential leadership amid threats to national security. But the real legacy of the leader of the Greatest Generation and the nation's most extraordinary president has been utterly lost. His Second Bill of Rights is largely forgotten, although, ironically, it has helped shape countless constitutions throughout the world -- including the interim Iraqi constitution. To some extent, it has guided our own deepest aspirations. And it helps us to straighten out some national confusions that were never more prominent, and more pernicious, than they are today.

It's past time to understand it.

Roosevelt began his speech by emphasizing that war was a shared endeavor in which the United States was simply one participant. Now that the war was in the process of being won, the main objective for the future could be "captured in one word: Security." Roosevelt argued that the term "means not only physical security which provides safety from attacks by aggressors," but also "economic security, social security, moral security." He insisted that "essential to peace is a decent standard of living for all individual men and women and children in all nations. Freedom from fear is eternally linked with freedom from want."

Moving to domestic affairs, Roosevelt emphasized the need to bring security to all American citizens. He argued for a "realistic tax law -- which will tax all unreasonable profits, both individual and corporate, and reduce the ultimate cost of the war to our sons and daughters." We "cannot be content, no matter how high that general standard of living may be, if some fraction of our people -- whether it be one-third or one-fifth or one-tenth -- is ill-fed, ill-clothed, ill-housed, and insecure," he declared.

At that point, the speech became spectacularly ambitious. Roosevelt looked back, not entirely approvingly, to the framing of the Constitution. At its inception, the nation had protected "certain inalienable political rights -- among them the right of free speech, free press, free worship, trial by jury, freedom from unreasonable searches and seizures," he noted. But over time, those rights had proved inadequate, as "we have come to a clear realization of the fact that true individual freedom cannot exist without economic security and independence."

"We have accepted, so to speak, a Second Bill of Rights under which a new basis of security and prosperity can be established for all -- regardless of station, race, or creed."

Then he listed the relevant rights:

The right to a useful and remunerative job in the industries or shops or farms or mines of the Nation.

The right to earn enough to provide adequate food and clothing and recreation.

The right of every farmer to raise and sell his products at a return which will give him and his family a decent living.

The right of every businessman, large and small, to trade in an atmosphere of freedom from unfair competition and domination by monopolies at home or abroad.

The right of every family to a decent home.

The right to adequate medical care and the opportunity to achieve and enjoy good health.

The right to adequate protection from the economic fears of old age, sickness, accident, and unemployment.

The right to a good education.

Having cataloged these eight rights, Roosevelt again made clear that the Second Bill of Rights was a continuation of the war effort. "America's own rightful place in the world depends in large part upon how fully these and similar rights have been carried into practice for our citizens. For unless there is security here at home there cannot be lasting peace in the world." He concluded that government should promote security instead of paying heed "to the whining demands of selfish pressure groups who seek to feather their nests while young Americans are dying."

Roosevelt, dead 15 months after delivering his speech, was unable to take serious steps toward putting his Bill of Rights into effect. But his proposal, now largely unknown within the United States, has had an extraordinary influence internationally. It played a major role in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, completed in 1948 under the leadership of Eleanor Roosevelt and publicly endorsed by American officials at the time. The declaration proclaims that everyone has the "right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing, and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age, or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control." The declaration also provides a right to education and social security. It proclaims that "everyone has the right to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favorable conditions of work and to protection against unemployment."

By virtue of its effect on the Universal Declaration, the Second Bill of Rights has influenced dozens of constitutions throughout the world. In one or another form, it can be found in countless political and legal documents. The current constitution of Finland guarantees everyone "the right to basic subsistence in the event of unemployment, illness, and disability and during old age as well as at the birth of a child or the loss of a provider." The constitution of Spain announces, "To citizens in old age, the public authorities shall guarantee economic sufficiency through adequate and periodically updated pensions." Similarly, the constitutions of Ukraine, Romania, Syria, Bulgaria, Hungary, Russia, and Peru recognize some or all of the social and economic rights cataloged by Franklin Roosevelt.

We might even call the Second Bill of Rights a leading American export. As the most recent example, consider the interim Iraqi constitution, written with American help and celebrated by the Bush administration. In Article XIV it proclaims, "The individual has the right to security, education, health care, and social security"; it adds that the nation and its government "shall strive to provide prosperity and employment opportunities to the people."

In fact, the United States itself continues to live, at least some of the time, under Roosevelt's constitutional vision. A consensus supports several of the rights he listed, including the right to education, the right to social security, the right to be free from monopoly, possibly even the right to a job. In the 1950s and 1960s, the U.S. Supreme Court started to go much further, embarking on a process of giving constitutional recognition to some of the rights that Roosevelt had listed. The court suggested that there might be some kind of right to an education; it ruled that people could not be deprived of welfare benefits without a hearing; it said that citizens from one state could not be subject to "waiting periods" that deprive them of financial and medical help in another state. In a 1970 decision, the court said: "Welfare, by meeting the basic demands of subsistence, can help bring within the reach of the poor the same opportunities that are available to others to participate meaningfully in the life of the community." Public assistance, the court added, "is not mere charity, but a means to 'promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity.'"

By the late 1960s, respected constitutional thinkers could conclude that the Supreme Court was on the verge of recognizing a right to be free from desperate conditions -- a right that captures much of what Roosevelt had cataloged. But all that was undone by the election of Richard Nixon in 1968. President Nixon promptly appointed four justices -- Warren E. Burger, William H. Rehnquist, Lewis F. Powell Jr., and Harry A. Blackmun -- who showed no interest in the Second Bill of Rights. In a series of decisions, the new justices, joined by one or two others, rejected the claim that the existing Constitution protects the kind of rights that Roosevelt had named.

Roosevelt himself did not argue for constitutional change. He wanted the Second Bill of Rights to be part of the nation's deepest commitments, to be recognized and vindicated by the public, not by federal judges. He trusted democratic processes, not judicial ones. Having seen many of his reforms struck down by the Supreme Court, he feared that judges would be unwilling to protect rights of the sort he favored. He thought that his bill should be seen in the same way as the Declaration of Independence -- as a statement of the fundamental aspirations of the United States. In fact, Roosevelt's speech echoed Thomas Jefferson's famous language with its own declaration: "In our day these economic truths have become accepted as self-evident."

But Roosevelt's hopes have not been realized. Much of the time, the United States seems to have embraced a confused and pernicious form of individualism, one that has no real foundations in our history. That approach endorses rights of private property and freedom of contract; it respects political liberty, but claims to distrust "government intervention" and to insist that people must largely fend for themselves. Its form of so-called individualism is incoherent -- a hopeless tangle of confusions. As Roosevelt well knew, no one is really against government intervention. The wealthy, at least as much as the poor, receive help from government and from the benefits that it bestows.

Roosevelt himself pointed to the essential problem as early as 1932. In a campaign address in San Francisco, he said that the exercise of "property rights might so interfere with the rights of the individual that the government, without whose assistance the property rights could not exist, must intervene, not to destroy individualism but to protect it." The key phrase here is "without whose assistance the property rights could not exist." Those of us who are doing well, and who have plenty of money and opportunities, owe a great deal to an active government that is willing and able to protect what we have. Once we can appreciate that point, we will find it impossible to complain about "government interference" as such or to urge, ludicrously, that our rights are best secured by getting government "off our backs." The same people who object to "government intervention" depend on it every day of every year.

Remarkably, the confusions that Roosevelt identified have had a rebirth since the early 1980s. Time and again, politicians argue that they oppose government intervention, even though property rights themselves cannot exist without such intervention. Time and again, American culture is said to be antagonistic to "positive rights," even though property rights themselves require "positive" action and even though the Second Bill of Rights helped to define our nation's political reforms for much of the 20th century. In recent years, we have been seeing the rise of a false and ahistorical picture of American culture and history, a picture that is increasingly prominent not just in America but also in Europe.

Unfortunately, that picture is far from innocuous. America's self-image -- our sense of ourselves -- has a significant impact on what we actually do. We should not look at ourselves through a distorted mirror.

Amid the war on terrorism, the problem goes even deeper. America should have taken the attacks of September 11, 2001, as the basis for a new recognition of human vulnerability and of our collective responsibilities to those who need help. Recall that threats from abroad led Roosevelt to a renewed emphasis on the importance of "security" -- with an understanding that the term included not merely protection against bullets and bombs, but also against hunger, disease, illiteracy, and desperate poverty. Hence President Roosevelt supported a strongly progressive income tax aimed at "unreasonable profits" and offering help for those at the bottom. By contrast, President Bush has supported a tax cut giving disproportionate help to those at the top. President Roosevelt saw the relationship between freedom from fear and freedom from want. Most important, he saw external threats as a reason to broaden the class of rights enjoyed by those at home. To say the least, President Bush has utterly failed to do the same.

Roosevelt was right. Liberty and citizenship are rooted in security. In a sense, America lives under the Second Bill of Rights. But in another sense, we have lost sight of it. It should be reclaimed in its nation of origin.

Cass R. Sunstein is a professor of political science at the University of Chicago and a professor of jurisprudence at the university's law school. His most recent book is The Second Bill of Rights: FDR's Unfinished Revolution and Why We Need It More Than Ever, to be published next month by Basic Books.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://chronicle.com
Section: The Chronicle Review
Volume 50, Issue 40, Page B9


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Copyright © 2004 by The Chronicle of Higher Education

Wednesday, June 02, 2004

http://www.misleader.org/daily_mislead

This is a good source for helping work through rhetoric and spin from the White House. It is a site that focuses on statements by President Bush. While there are a lot of groups that will rebut or decry the president's comments, this site endeavors to document both the president's comments and their rebuttal.

Well, all presidents do it...

Recently in an article on MSNBC.com (I confess I didn't keep the URL to the article, and I forget the print magazine in which this will appear, but I'm sure you can search it)I read that President Bush has Saddam Hussein's gun. Now, I can really understand why Bush wanted that gun as a memento, but...

"The magazine quoted a visitor who had been shown the gun, which is kept in a small study off the Oval Office where Bush displays memorabilia. It is the same room where former President Clinton had some of his encounters with former intern Monica Lewinsky."

Why don't we just call it: "The Designated Room for Presidential Stupidity."

Thursday, May 20, 2004

Women in the Military

The following letter was written to and published by the Seattle Post-Intelligencer newspaper on Monday, May 17, 2004:

Photos raise concern about women in military

With the photos of how women in the Iraqi prison have behaved, I regard this
as a microcosm of the trend of American society.

Violence committed by women is on the rise, as reflected in the Seattle
Post-Intelligencer on Thursday. How many women are in prison in this state
now for rape of a child? The incidence of stepmothers sexually abusing
stepsons is rising dramatically.

Then, there is the whole issue of women in the military. Our aircraft
carriers and larger ships have become floating houses of ill repute. Any
time a carrier returns from deployment, a significant percentage of women,
both single and married to men not on board the ship, are pregnant. Lyndee
England claims she is now pregnant from her multiple liaisons at the prison,
and that problem of pregnancy exists in high percentage in every military
service. Sexual related issues are at an all-time high in the military.

If the true story of the broad spectrum of sexual escapades as occurred in
Gulf War I were ever published by the press, the American public would
respond in horror. The recurring complaint of men at service academies, boot
camps and field training exercises is that the men have to assist women and
gun-deck the records because the women can't make it physically. Women are
plainly a distraction from the mission of our military.

I have ruefully come 180 degrees around to the conclusion that women have no
place in our military. Some societies can handle women in their respective
militaries; ours cannot. I am retired military and have represented many
women in my law specialty of military and military-related matters.

Rightly or wrongly, women have been historically and presently are the
keepers of the public morals in American society, and they are failing
everywhere in this very special charge. It is something we will have to live
with in other areas of our society, and let us retain the advances women
have made in other fields, but forget the military. Such is plainly is not
working, and this well-intentioned experiment must end.

J. Byron Holcomb
Bainbridge Island

Tuesday, May 18, 2004

The Thinking Woman's Guide to Politics, Media and Life

Welcome to the Thinking Woman, an exercise in empowering women by clearly explaining what you see and hear on the television, radio, print media, Internet and from the mouths of friends and relatives.

We are two women who could not be more different. One of us is a member of the East Coast Jewish media elite. A single mother and professional writer and editor who commutes from New England to Manhattan every day. The other is a stay-at-home mother of two, wife and transplanted Midwestern Lutheran living in the beautiful Pacific Northwest. What we have in common is a publishing background, liberal politics and a growing uneasiness with the disfranchisement of our women friends. They feel disconnected, helpless and often confused.

We will occasionally express our own views on current events, and how we see them affecting the lives of women. And our opinions will most likely have a liberal slant. But our goal is not to create another liberal site. It is to help women cut through the "spin", fluff, and doubletalk on all sides of an issue.

Women made the difference for Bill Clinton in 1994. They can make the difference again, not just in the 2004 election year, but in American life in general.

We're here to help our friends become informed, aware and involved. This is the Thinking Woman's guide to politics, the media and life. The fun has just begun. Won't you join us?