Tuesday, November 09, 2004

"Moral" Values?

Monday morning, Al Franken made a point heard muttered frequently around The Thinking Woman since Wednesday. (Context: Rush Limbaugh -- who as we know is a saint -- claims that the Democrats want to eliminate any morality whatsoever from the world.)

Just about every issue in the election was a moral issue. The war in Iraq, Social Security security, etc., are all moral issues. In fact, we at the Thinking Woman think that everyone who voted voted on moral values, because our moral compass influences our attitude toward many issues addressed by the government.

So the question is not one of morality, but of how much the government has a right, constitutionally, to impose one set of moral values on a whole nation.

In an article in The Slate, Paul Freedman, associate professor of Politics at the University of Virginia, argues that that what really drove people to vote for Bush was terrorism, not "moral values" (defined primarily as attitudes toward gay marriage and abortion). We think he has a point. Read it for yourself, and see if you agree:

http://slate.msn.com/id/2109275/

Thursday, November 04, 2004

Four More Years

After a divisive election campaign, the cessation of all the passion, intensity and hard work is a bit of a let down. For the Kerry supporters, it is more than that. But even the feeling for Bush supporters has to be more one of relief than of euphoria.

One thing the 2004 presidential election map made clear: America is blue around the edges, which is an apt description of how some of us have felt this week. But before 48 percent of our readers give in to depression, let’s review some facts.

In spite of President Bush’s claims of a mandate, he was only elected by a three percent majority of voters. This is a very small margin, much too small, we think, to be claiming that America wants to dwell permanently on the right.

Overlooked here is how the choice of Democratic candidate may have affected voters. Was John Kerry a man Americans could easily identify with and believe in? In spite of his many positive attributes, we don’t think so.

However, given Kerry’s sometimes aloof and aristocratic bearing, a huge percentage of the population still voted for him. Some of this may have been the ABB (anyone but Bush) vote but it does showcase the anger many Americans feel. And when you come right down to it, Americans chose their candidate on Tuesday based on whether they were angry or afraid.

Kerry’s supporters were angry. Angry at discrimination, diminishing personal rights, rising unemployment and health care costs, escalating war and terrorism, and forced conservative values.

Bush’s supporters were afraid. Afraid of terrorism, liberal values, homosexuals and taxes.

As Jon Stewart pointed out on The Daily Show on November 3, it’s ironic that the people who live closest to two of the latter fears aren’t afraid at all. New Yorkers, who count gay neighbors among their friends and associates, and experienced the full brutality of September 11 firsthand, voted overwhelmingly for Kerry.

Still, we are now faced with a new order of things. The Republicans will control the House and Senate, making it very hard to push anything construed as a liberal agenda. It also means that the remaining Democrats could make things impossible for Bush. The Senate needs 60 votes to pass a bill and only 55 belong to Republicans. If the Dems dig in their heels, we could be looking at four years of gridlock.

However, we hope that won’t happen. We hope that Americans will come together to find common ground and start the healing process. We hope that Bush will make true his campaign promise in 2000 and finally prove to the American people that he’s a uniter, not a divider.

As Abraham Lincoln once observed, “a house divided against itself will not stand.” If President Bush wants to make good his promise of a stronger America, he would do well to remember that

Tuesday, November 02, 2004

Election Day -- Have you voted yet?

Today is Election Day.

It's time to vote, if you haven't already!

But if you are still undecided about who to vote for, there is still some time to do research. An excellent source for cutting through the spin and exaggeration is www.factcheck.org , the site Vice President Cheney mistakenly referred to in his debate with John Edwards as factcheck.com.

Factcheck.org strives to be nonpartisan, and focuses on the exaggerations and misrepresentations, presenting raw facts to put them into perspective. You can also go back and read the party platforms, links for which are found on this blog.

Finally, regardless of where you vote, there are a few things that are true everywhere:

You are entitled to the time to vote. Most states have liberal voting hours. But employers are required to allow you the time to go vote.

If you are in line when the closing time is reached, you are still entitled to vote. Stay in line as long as it takes to cast your ballot.

Poll workers are there to help you -- you can ask questions and get help if you need it. Do not feel awkward about asking for assistance in understanding and completing your ballot.

If you live in west, don't let the earlier returns from the East Coast discourage you from voting. This year is a very close race, and the last vote cast in Hawaii is as important as the first vote cast in Maine. And remember, you are voting for more than a president, you are voting for state and local offices and issues, as well.

If for some reason there is a question about your eligibility to vote, you can cast a provisional ballot.

And most important, have fun!

Monday, October 18, 2004

The Final Debate

The final debate is over, and we are left with spin doctors and campaign speeches to help us decide who should be the next president.

Thursday night's theme could be, "But Iraq IS a domestic issue!" Although the debate was to be devoted to Domestic Issues, the candidates were more animated when given the opportunity to discuss foreign policy and the war in Iraq.

How did the candidates look?
Both candidates appeared relaxed and confident, especially President Bush. At times John Kerry looked as if he was having the time of his life. Both candidates appeared well-prepared, and unruffled when challenged by the opposing candidate. Both candidates made some mistakes in "facts", but not many, and when debating without notes it is impressive when there are so few mistakes made.

Who won the debate?
Well, even the Republicans are conceding that Kerry has gained an advantage. As Ralph Reed told John Stewart on The Daily Show, John Kerry is a formidable debater. He debated in college, and his debate coach at Yale said he was one of the top five best debaters he had ever seen or coached. So no wonder he looked like he was enjoying himself -- John Kerry loves to debate. He looked and sounded presidential. He was effective in presenting specific strategies for addressing and dealing with the present problems facing the country.

President Bush stayed on message, as he has in previous debates. The president's main message is to trust him to do the right thing. He also hammered home his commitment to education as the key to the problems that face the nation. He spoke like someone who understands from experience the job of the president, and he projected the warmth and congeniality that gained him a reputation for being a uniter when he was governor of Texas.

Even so, the edge went to John Kerry, who had more substance to his statements, and never avoided a question.

What mistakes were made?
Both candidates had the usual factual inaccuracies (although none as good as Vice President Cheney recommending factcheck.com, an ad site originating in the Cayman Islands, as a source for accurate information instead of factcheck.org), but more than that, they made a couple of strategic errors. President Bush evaded a direct question about abortion rights, giving Sen. Kerry the opportunity to point that out. When asked about what he would say to someone who was laid off because of outsourcing, his reply was to hand the person some money to go to a local community college to gain the skills to look for a new job. It lacked compassion, and adhered to the erroneous assumption that people who are outsourced are minimum wage earners with no training.

Senator Kerry cited Vice President Cheney's daughter, who happens to be a lesbian as well as the vice president's campaign manager, when talking about gay marriage. The post-debate furor over that remark has focused attention on the ire of the Cheneys and diverting attention from Senator Kerry's plans.

Bob Shieffer lobbed the candidates a couple of softball questions. His question about the strong women in the lives of the two men prompted a warm, sweet account by the president of love at first sight when he met his wife, and a joke about marrying up from the usually serious Kerry. It was heartening to see that both men are, like the rest of us, more than their jobs, but fathers and husbands.

So now we count down to the election. As the spin masters go into high gear it is important to remember that the platforms of each candidate, and the substance of the debates, should weigh heavily into which candidate to choose. Both men are strongly committed to their ideals, and there is a clear difference between them.

Most importantly, choose and vote.

Wednesday, October 06, 2004

Who Let The Dogs Out? The Cheney/Edwards Debate

The attack dogs were worked up to a lather last night as Vice President Dick Cheney and Sen. John Edwards (D-NC) went at each other like chained Rottweilers.

Characterized by WFAN radio personality Don Imus as a duel between "Dr. Death and the Breck Girl," the debate was punctuated with heated exchanges, counter-rebuttals and claims of distortion by both parties.

Unlike the gentlemanly presidential debate that clearly laid out what each candidate stood for and believed in, the vice presidential debate was an exercise in redundancy as the debaters circled around the same topics again and again much like attack dogs on a chain.

Was there a winner?

Well, to give the vice president his due, he was far more clear and concise than his opponent. Of course, it is easy to be clear when you are repeating the same assertions over and over no matter what the question. But that doesn't mean that Cheney didn't have his moments.

Particularly memorable was his line about Edward not showing up for Senate votes. Cheney said something to the affect of "I am the president of the Senate and have been there almost every Tuesday. Senator, the first time I met you was when you walked on stage this evening."

Unfortunately for the vice president, that's not true, since there is video showing them shaking hands at a National Prayer Breakfast, and later being thanked by name by the vice president. However, it doesn't negate the fact that the senator has been pretty busy running for office.

In spite of his youthful demeanor and his high-speed zooming from one topic to the next, Edwards proved himself a tough opponent. He never let a single assertion go unchallenged or unexplained and was well versed on facts.

He also had his moment when in true litagational style he backed Cheney into a corner on the question of an amendment to abolish gay marriage. By framing it totally in the context of a compliment to Cheney's family about his gay daughter, he left the vice president with only one reply: "Thank you."

Besides the often sharp rebuttals and character slams, we found the hand gestures of both candidates distracting. Edwards combined the Clintonesque pointing with a closed hand with other restless movements. Cheney continually wrang his hands in a way that makes us think of, well, the elderly. Didn't their handlers warn them about this? We never thought that Kerry's chopping and Bush's palm slapping would look restful by comparison.

Both candidates had their share of distortions -- never call them lies in politics!

For instance, Edwards claimed that the cost of war is over $200 billion when it hasn't yet reached that amount, and Cheney inflated the number of small businesses that will be affected if the tax cuts are rolled back.

In 2000, Cheney and then vice presidential nominee Joe Lieberman gave such an intelligent, gentlemanly and mature debate that the entire country asked why they weren't at the top of their respective tickets. We at The Thinking Woman have no concerns that those sentiments will be repeated after this year's debate.

A source for analyzing the factual errors in last night's debate can be found in the American Progress Action Fund's Progress Report:
http://www.americanprogressaction.org/

Monday, October 04, 2004

Bush's Home Town Newspaper Endorses Kerry

It has come to the attention of The Thinking Woman, through The Capital Times, an on-line newspaper at madison.com, that the Lone Star Iconoclast has endorsed John Kerry in the 2004 presidential election.

Why is this extraordinary? The Iconoclast is the newspaper in President George W. Bush's home town of Crawford, Texas.

While presidents are not always popular in their home towns, it seems remarkable that a newspaper that heartily endorsed the president during the 2000 campaign and strongly supported his bid to go to Iraq, would decided to instead to not even reluctantly but enthusiastically endorse his opponent.

While mentioning the president's foreign policy, the Iconoclast focuses on economic issues -- Medicare, Social Security, job outsourcing and overtime pay to name just a few. The editorial accuses the president of "duping" the American people, and pursuing an agenda that was not part of his campaign platform.

While newspaper endorsements should always be considered just one piece of the decision process in an election, a home town's defection should never be taken lightly.

To read the Iconoclast's entire editorial: http://http://www.madison.com/tct/opinion/index.php?ntid=11655&ntpid=1


Saturday, October 02, 2004

Who Won the First Debate?

When we started The Thinking Woman our primary goal was to cut through the spin and the media hype so that women could get a clear picture of what is happening in politics, the media and the world in general.

That mission is never more important than now, when our presidential candidates have on their game faces and their people are furiously spinning to suit their own ends. We don't blame them for this, it's what politicians do. But we're not politicians and we don't have to listen to what the pundits tell us. Neither should you.

Before we examine the first 2004 presidential debate, we'd like to make a suggestion. Watch the debates on C-SPAN where you'll see both candidates on a split screen with no network commentator telling you what you already heard in plain English. Don't listen to the network news or any commentators, not even if you swear by Al Franken or Rush Limbaugh.

Instead, decide for yourself.

(If you really need to watch something, watch Jon Stewart on the Daily Show on Comedy Central. The cast's wisecracking is pretty bipartisan. But then, that's just our opinion.)

What did we think of the debate? We'd have to say that both candidates presented themselves well and in a way that is appealing to their core constituencies.

The positives
President George W. Bush appeared firm and resolute, unyielding yet humble and even exhausted by the heavy burden the fight against terrorism has laid on his shoulders. He was a gentleman at all times and even softened Kerry up by complimenting his daughters and getting the senator to show his more human side.

Senator John Kerry appeared intelligent, firm and decisive. He showed himself to be a thinking man, well in touch with the facts, versed in diplomacy and ready to do whatever it takes to fight the war on terrorism. He never went over the line set by President Bush and graciously gave a touching tribute to the First Lady.

The negatives
Bush needed to pause often to collect his thoughts and occasionally appeared uncomfortable. Kerry came off as smug a few times and his long sentences at the beginning had us squirming in our seats. But basically, we felt these flaws were small and didn't affect the tone of the debate, which was substantive.

So substantive in fact, that we think that the American people got a clear and positive choice between the two candidates.

The differences
Both men want to bring our troops home, both men want to protect our country from terrorists and both men want to see an end to nuclear proliferation.

Bush presented a policy of staying the course and continuing the fight.

Kerry outlined proposals to bring in European allies and get our troops out of Iraq withing six months.

Bush sees Vladimir Putin of Russia as an ally. Kerry does not.

Bush sees China as an ally in controlling North Korea. Kerry does not.

Kerry sees the United Nations as a potential tool to eventual peace. Bush does not.

And Kerry would make modifications to the Patriot Act, where Bush would not.

The choice
Bush: Stand strong and go it alone to get the job done right.

Kerry: Build consensus and draw in allies to share the burden and improve America's relationship with the world.

Who you think will make a better president is up to you. We think you now have a clear choice.

So who won Thursday night's debate?

Isn't it obvious?

The American people won.

Wednesday, September 29, 2004

Critical Thinking In Utah

Utah Valley State College has invited film maker Michael Moore to speak to its student body. This is so controversial that a panel discussion about Moore's appearance was packed. One item from the Salt Lake Tribune's account of the meeting astounded us:

"Kay Anderson, father of a UVSC student who lives next to Sederburg, called his appearance an insult to the community. 'I should not have to send my children to a private university to get a conservative education when I live in a conservative community and have a state college in my back yard that is paid for by conservative taxpayers and donors,' he said. 'A balanced education does not require we teach our children to be so open-minded that their brains fall out.'

Anderson held up a cashier's check for $25,000 to help restoke student-body coffers if student President Jim Bassi and Vice President Joe Vogel rescind the Moore invitation.

But Anderson's offer drew hisses and boos from the capacity crowd. Even a petition to recall the two student leaders reportedly has stalled."
excerpt: Salt Lake Tribune: http://www.sltrib.com/ci_2418051

Two things are astonishing, one of them gravely disturbing. First, the expectation that a public university, subject to state and federal guidelines, will provide the same philisophical approach to education as a private college or university.

Second, and this is the disturbing part, the idea that being open-minded is a bad thing. We at The Thinking Woman were taught that anything worthwhile will hold up to challenge and scrutiny. We were sent to college with the hopes of our developing that skill. Certainly this applies to religious faith and should apply to all areas of life. Like it or not, all adults ultimately form their own set of values. What we learn from our parents will not leave us.

But try to insulate, to discriminate, to isolate, can backfire so that children will reject the very core values their parents hold sacred.

It's not the children's brains but their values we're worried about.

Wednesday, September 22, 2004

What Do Women Want? An Open Letter To Senator John Kerry (D-MA)

Dear Senator Kerry,

There has been a lot written in the press lately about how you are losing women’s votes. As two women who represent your Democratic core, we would like to tell you what we, as women, want to hear.

While we’re proud that as a son of privilege you volunteered for Vietnam, we’re sick of hearing about it. Ditto all the allegations about George W. Bush shirking his military service. It’s time to give up this nonsense. It has little impact on our lives today. Frankly, we’re sick of it and it’s making the two of you look like spiteful little boys, not accomplished men.

As Democrats, we want you to keep asking and demanding the answer to: “Are you really better off than you were four years ago?”

We need to hear how you are going to keep us safe. Not broad promises but actual plans where you tell us (in laymen’s terms) what you will do to achieve your goals.

We need to hear what you are going to do so that we can have what we need to take care of our children. Talk to us about how you are going bolster the economy and support small businesses, a great many of which are run by women. Tell us how we can be sure our children will be fed, well educated and have their medical needs looked after.

Tell us how we can find and keep a home if we are poor. Tell us what you will do when we are left without a man in our lives, especially the majority of us who will outlive our mates. Tell us that your plans to make sure we won’t spend our old age living in a closet eating cat food.

We need to hear optimism. Yes, “Hope is on the Way” is an uplifting slogan, but we also need to hear creativity. What new ideas have you come up with that will give us reason to believe that hope really is on the way?

We need to see the real you. You are still pretty much a tall cipher with great hair, a winning smile and a rich wife. We don’t know you and as women we are very interested in what makes a person tick. We are also appreciative of men who make us feel safe because they are honorable, decent and kind. If you are these things, show us.

Lastly, treat us as intelligent human beings and you’ll win our confidence. Treat our concerns seriously and you’ll win our respect. Treat our needs as an important part of your campaign and you’ll win our vote. That’s what women want. It couldn’t be any simpler than that.

Sincerely,
The Thinking Women

Tuesday, September 14, 2004

A brief discussion of various styles of primaries

Since the Supreme Court ruled in 2000 that the California open primary was unconstitutional, other states have had to revise their approaches to their primaries. Here, briefly, is a general explanation of some of the various primaries:

"Blanket" primary
A blanket primary is similar to a general election. Voters can jump around on the ballot, voting for whom they choose. The idea behind this form of primary is to allow people to choose the candidate they most prefer, giving party affiliation little importance. Candidates are still associated with a party, and each party's candidate with the most votes (in a contested primary) moves on to be that party's candidate in the general election in November. Until the Supreme Court rule it as unconstitutional, this system was used in Washington, California and Alaska.

"Closed" Primary
Most states use a primary system in which voters can select only within a party. In some states, a voter has to actually register as a party member in order to vote in that party's primary. Whether or not a voter registers a party affiliation, at the polling place the voter must "declare" a party to vote, either to receive the proper ballot, or to have the voting machine set to prevent "crossing over." This system is disliked because, especially in small communities, the anonimity of one's party affiliation can be questionable. This problem is often alleviated by printing all parties on one ballot, with the choices made completely in the voting booth.

Louisiana System
In Louisiana, voters can choose any candidate from any political party in the opening round of voting. If one candidate wins a majority of votes cast, that candidate is declared the winner. If no candidate wins a majority, the top two vote-getters -- regardless of party affiliation -- move on to the general election.

Every woman should register -- and vote

Women make up 51 percent of eligible voters. Yet 50 million women did not vote in the last election.

Not even a hundred years ago, women marched, protested the office of the president, and were unconstitutionally arrested, imprisoned and brutalized as part of the effort to win women the right to vote. Their argument? Taxation without representation is unconstitutional.

Any person eligible who does not register and take the time to vote is essentially being taxed without representation. We as women should honor the women who worked tirelessly to gain us the right to vote by voting our consciences. Many of these pioneers never lived to exercise their right.

This Saturday, a progressive coalition called America Votes will register as many people as possible, especially women, on what they are calling a National Women's Election Action Day. We at The Thinking Woman support and applaud this large-scale effort to register every eligible voter.

Of course, you don't have to be a progressive to vote. No matter what your political philosophy, make certain you are legally registered to vote. Check with your secretary of state's office or local voter registration office to verify that you are registered. If you are not, make sure you register in time for the November election. The deadline on this varies from state to state, so inquire now.

Let's make this year the year that the president was elected by a true representation of voters.

Remember, not voting is akin to taxation without representation.

  • Women Should Vote Because:*
    We are 51 percent of the population, and with this majority voice we CAN influence the direction of critical policies important to us -- like childcare, choice, personal safety, economic security and a healthy environment.
  • We are not effectively exercising our hard-earned constitutional right. 22 million registered unmarried women did not vote in the last election. And more than 50 million eligible women -- married and unmarried -- are not even registered to vote.
  • A poll last year of some 3,000 women of diverse backgrounds conducted by the women’s voting project Women's Voices, Women's Votes found that 65 percent of the women polled believe this country is going in the wrong direction.
  • Based on the findings of a recent survey by Business and Professional Women USA, retirement security, job opportunity, good schools and housing costs are all of HIGHER importance to women than homeland security.
  • Voting statistics among all women can be improved. According to the U.S. Census bureau in 2000, some 30 percent of eligible women were not registered to vote.
  • Registering is only half the battle. Almost half of registered unmarried women don't vote. If they turned out in numbers, unmarried women would be the largest voting bloc and would be the deciding "X" factor in close elections.

*from MOVEONPAC

Thursday, September 09, 2004

Just what we don't need...digital women as pinups

The Associated Press recently reported that Playboy will be featuring (female) video game characters as pinups:


Playboy is taking a chance on silicon instead of silicone. The October issue of the men's magazine features several video game characters posing in the nude -- images created by the game companies through detailed computer illustration.

"Hopefully, the purists won't get too bent out of shape. This is just the next version of the pinup," said Playboy senior editor Scott Alexander, who developed the project.
The computerized models are part of the magazine's video game preview, titled "Gaming Grows Up." The five-page section starts with a topless image of the half-vampire, half-human title character from "BloodRayne," a leather-clad woman who fights with 3-foot blades attached to her arms...Digital women could become a regular feature if readers approve.



Now, we at The Thinking Woman are firm supporters of the freedom of the press. But this goes too far.

We can argue that digital pinups already exist. It's widely known that Playboy has been using air brushing for years to bring perfection to their pinups. But air brushing, digital enhancement and other techniques are commonly used in many publications to make models and celebrities alike look "perfect." So why not take it one step further, and eliminate the real person? Just create the impossibly ideal woman -- don't forget the weaponry! -- and fantasize about her, instead.

Of course, Playboy for years has been publishing erotic drawings and paintings. But here's the difference: A picture stays a picture, and remains a piece of paper. A digital person can be animated to move, talk, and live in such a realistic world that they can become as real a character as any created by an actor on film.

Let's be realistic. A large portion of Playboy's readership is under age 18. Do we really want our sons thinking this is an achievable norm? It puts even more pressure on our daughters, in a society already unhealthily fixated on appearence, to try to achieve an impossible-for-most body image.

At a time in life when boys and girls should be developing relationship skills, they do not need to have the additional pressure of competing with a fantasy woman.

Saturday, September 04, 2004

Ralph Nader's list of issues link

http://www.votenader.org/issues/index_home.php

Democratic Party Platform link

http://a9.g.akamai.net/7/9/8082/v001/www.democrats.org/pdfs/2004platform.pdf

Please note: You will need Adobe Acrobat Reader for this link. If you are unable to access, please let us know and we will help you find the text.

Republican Party Platform link

Full text: http://www.gop.com/About/PartyPlatform/Default.aspx

The importance of Platforms

We have heard John Kerry and George W. Bush speak at their respective conventions. And both will be doing a lot of persuasive speaking in coming weeks up to the election. And both sides will spend millions on advertising, trying to convince us to vote for their candidate.

But when we make our choice, we need to go beyond the campaign rhetoric. It is important to read the platforms of the parties, because a party's nominee is pledged to uphold the party's platform and represent not just himself, but the approved agenda of his or her party.

That is why The Thinking Woman is publishing links to the full text for the platforms for the two parties along with a link to Ralph Nader's list of issues. (We have been unable to find the full text as yet of his party platform.)

At this time we are not including the platforms for other parties, but that may change in the coming weeks.

It is a lot of reading, but please take the time to read the platforms. These, more than anything else, will tell you exactly where the candidates stand.

Tuesday, August 31, 2004

Oh...the military delegates at the GOP Convention are reservists....

According to Eric Alterman, it seems that the "active" military personnel who are delegates at the Republican National Convention are reservists, so they are okay to be delegates:

"Update on my Possible Actual News Alert: According to our man Bateman, whom we should have contacted in the first place, the Republican Party is not in violation of the U.S. military’s rules on the participation in party politics by active duty military, owing to the reserve status of the delegates."

We have to ask, though, if the reserves are being sent into active duty, why is there a distinction for political activity and not being sent to Iraq?

Monday, August 30, 2004

Active servicemen serving as delegates?

The following appears today in Eric Alterman's column online on msnbc.com. (For the entire column: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/3449870/) Props to Michael Galletly for his vigilance! We at The Thinking Woman hesitate to call this a conspiracy (although the word has been muttered) but it certainly seems to be something the Republican Party itself would be anxious to clear up. The last thing they want is an appearance of inpropriety as they are the party of the sitting president:

Possible Actual News Alert: Is the Republican Party in violation of the US military’s rules on the participation in party politics by active duty military?

It sure looks that way. The RNC convention week is boasting that it has 144 active duty military delegates at the convention or three percent of the total. That information can be found here.

Meanwhile, according to DOD Directive 1344.10, which can be found here this is a violation of the code of military conduct.

It explicitly says:

"A member on active duty shall not ... Participate in partisan political management, campaigns, or conventions (unless attending a convention as a spectator when not in uniform)."

But the Republican Party itself is claiming that the active duty personnel are not spectators but delegates. What’s going on here? Why are the Republicans encouraging our soldiers to violate the Uniform Code of Military Justice and its stated rules of political engagement? And why for goodness sakes, aren’t these rules being enforced?

Hey MSNBC.com, can we put a reporter or two on this story please?

(Thanks to Altercation reader Michael Galletly of Norman, OK.)

Wednesday, August 25, 2004

Cheney Earns our Admiration

The thinking women behind The Thinkingwoman are not given to praising Republicans too often, so imagine our surprise when we have good things to say about two of them in a given week. However, in a New York Times article by Robin Toner this morning (Aug. 25) Cheney was quoted about his opinion on gay marriage.

--- In a political season marked by Republican efforts to outlaw gay marriage, Vice President Dick Cheney on Tuesday offered a defense of the rights of gay Americans, declaring that "freedom means freedom for everyone" to enter "into any kind of relationship they want to."

--- Mr. Cheney said the issue was what kind of government recognition to give those relationships, and indicated that he preferred to let the states define what constitutes a marriage.

The critics immediately started sniping that Cheney was only trying to soften the harsh tone of the Bush administration calling for a constitutional amendment to prevent gay marriage. We believe otherwise. Back in 2000 we were struck by the civil and intelligent content of Cheney’s debate with then vice presidential nominee Joe Lieberman. During their discussion the issue of the place of homosexuals in our society came up and both men agreed that they needed to learn more and remain open-minded about the topic. Since that time, Cheney has admitted that one of his two daughters is gay and has stated that he is as proud of her as her sister.

This doesn’t sound like a man who is playing a game for his administration. This strikes us as a good father who is standing by what he believes in spite of his party’s platform. We’d like to offer our praise and encouragement for this principled stance. We only wish we saw more of this in politics.

Tuesday, August 24, 2004

John McCain and the 2004 presidential election

We at The Thinking Women are fans of John McCain, the moderate Republican senator from Arizona. We have found ourselves frequently discussing him lately. We liked him as a running mate for John Kerry, and, for that matter, we liked him as the Republican presidential candidate in 2000. (And, for that matter, he'd make a great running mate for George W. Bush!)

Which brings up why he is being discussed by us so much now. It turns out that the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth are essentially the same group of people who ran a successful negative ad campaign against John McCain in 2000, enabling George W. Bush to gain the Republican nomination. And so, instead of running for re-election as president, Sen. McCain is running for re-election as senator in Arizona. (If being a war veteran were the main criteria for being president, there's no question his experiences and heroism far outstrips anyone else who has run for the office of president in the last twenty years. )

One of us was led to comment today that if John McCain were president, America wouldn't be in the mess we are today. And we asked (as we seem to do almost weekly), how could the GOP nominate George W. Bush over John McCain?

Which brings us back to the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth. The conservative right appears to, right now, have the power (especially the money) in the Republican Party and they, by hook or crook (heh heh) got their candidate into office. John McCain is too moderate for the Republicans right now. Which is sad, because the country is being denied the Republican who has the true potential to unite a polarized nation.